Home heating
Life-cycle comparison of the three most common New Zealand household heaters — heat pump, wood stove and electric oil column heater (Bakshi, Vale & Vale 2013).
Heating demand · Select city
- Annual heat demand
- 0 kWh/yr
- Peak envelope loss
- 0.00 kW
- Heating degree days
- 0 K·day (base 18)
- Floor area
- 0.0 m²
Appliance sizing guide: 0.00 kW output (peak loss +15% margin). Enter surface dimensions to size the appliance. WHO recommends a minimum 18 °C indoors, 16 °C in bedrooms overnight.
Fuel prices & carbon
Annual life-cycle energy by appliance
- Heat pump (high-wall split)366 MJ/yrAppliance EE 366 · fuel EE 0 · fuel content 0 MJ
- Wood stove (enclosed burner + flue)153 MJ/yrAppliance EE 153 · fuel EE 0 · fuel content 0 MJ
- Electric oil-filled column heater223 MJ/yrAppliance EE 223 · fuel EE 0 · fuel content 0 MJ
Running cost, fuel and carbon
- Heat pump (high-wall split)COP/efficiency 5.56Fuel used0 kWhAnnual cost$0Annual carbon0 kg CO₂eLifetime energy (10 yr)3,655 MJ
- Wood stove (enclosed burner + flue)69% efficientFuel used0.00 t firewoodAnnual cost$0Annual carbon0 kg CO₂eLifetime energy (25 yr)3,812 MJ
- Electric oil-filled column heaterCOP/efficiency 1.00Fuel used0 kWhAnnual cost$0Annual carbon0 kg CO₂eLifetime energy (3 yr)670 MJ
Heat pump (high-wall split) — embodied energy
Mitsubishi SRK20ZJX-S · assumed life 10 years · 3,655 MJ total, annualised to 366 MJ/yr.
- Cast iron · 37.9 kg × 70 MJ/kg2653 MJ
- Galvanised steel · 12 kg × 34.8 MJ/kg418 MJ
- Copper tubing · 6.4 kg × 70.6 MJ/kg452 MJ
- Refrigerant fluid (R-600a) · 2.7 kg × 49.1 MJ/kg133 MJ
EECA ENERGY STAR top performer at COP 5.56 (7 °C, H1). 10-year life assumed because the rated COP is only guaranteed for 10 years. Lowest overall life-cycle energy of the three systems studied.
New Zealand electricity mix (2023)
- Hydro · 55.7%55 kJ/kWh
- Geothermal · 18.0%95 kJ/kWh
- Gas · 9.4%11537 kJ/kWh
- Wind · 6.5%70 kJ/kWh
- Coal · 5.7%3714 kJ/kWh
- Co-generation, biogas and waste · 4.1%2600 kJ/kWh
- Solar PV · 0.6%430 kJ/kWh
- Renewable share
- 84.9%
- Grid carbon (default)
- 0.074 kg CO₂e/kWh
- Embodied energy of electricity
- 1458 kJ/kWh
- EE coefficient
- 0.40
New Zealand generation is dominated by hydro and geothermal, so delivered electricity carries little upstream energy and very low carbon. Heat pumps are therefore the lowest life-cycle energy and carbon option in almost every New Zealand climate; dry-year thermal peaking (gas and coal at Huntly) is the main source of variation between years.
Mix: MBIE Energy in New Zealand / Electricity statistics (2023 calendar year) — ~87% renewable generation. Carbon: Ministry for the Environment, Measuring emissions: a guide for organisations (2023) — electricity consumption factor. Firewood: 16.2 MJ/kg delivered energy content with 5% embodied energy. The source paper's reference case supplies 3,604 kWh of heat per year to a single room (New Zealand 2009 mix, 3008 kJ/kWh, coefficient 0.84).
Data sources
- Bakshi, N., Vale, R. & Vale, B. (2013) “Which heater should I choose? A comparative study of appliances and fuel sources”, Cutting Edge: 47th International Conference of the Architectural Science Association (ANZAScA), pp. 335–344
- Alcorn, A. (2003) Embodied Energy and CO₂ Coefficients for New Zealand Building Materials, Centre for Building Performance Research, Victoria University of Wellington
- EECA (2013) ENERGY STAR appliance ratings and Energy End Use Database — space heating is ~29% of typical NZ household energy
- Ministry for the Environment (2013) recommended low-emission wood burners; NES for Air Quality burner rules
- Rule, B. (2009) New Zealand electricity generation mix — 55.2% hydro, 21.8% gas, 12.2% coal, 7.6% geothermal, 3.2% wind
- Isaacs, N. et al. (2006) Energy Use in New Zealand Households (HEEP Year 10), BRANZ — space heating ≈ one third of household energy
- ISO 14040:1997 Environmental Management — Life Cycle Assessment: Principles and Framework
- World Health Organization recommended minimum indoor temperature 18 °C (16 °C in bedrooms overnight)
⚠️ Life-cycle figures are drawn from a 2013 New Zealand study of a single-room heating regime and are scaled to this building's steady-state heat demand. They exclude installation, maintenance, transport of fuel, comfort and air-quality effects, and assume a fixed electricity generation mix. Use for comparison and feasibility only; confirm appliance selection with the current EECA/manufacturer data and your local council's air-quality rules.
